American Idol: Top 24 (Girls)
Feb. 23rd, 2010 10:40 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
butterflyI enjoyed this so much more than the Audition and Hollywood episodes. If I decide to watch the show again next year, I won't start until semi-finals. I watched this with my mom and she really got into it!
Okay, here goes...
1) Paige - she started the night off well with her performance. Powerful voice. I don't really remember seeing/hearing her before now but I really liked her sound.
2) Ashley - Didn't like the song very much. And she felt a little too smooth... didn't hit me the right way.
3) Janelle - Not terrific. Bad song choice (again - lots of those tonight).
4) Lilly - very jazzy voice; really liked what she did with the song.
5) Katelyn - Really good voice. Better than I remembered from before.
6) Haeley - Oh, horrible song choice for her and I didn't like what she did with it, either. Just didn't work for me at all.
7) Lacey - I love this song but I hated what she did with it. Did not like at all.
8) Michelle - I really enjoyed this one. Nice vibe; liked the song.
9) Didi - I don't know what Simon is smoking, to be honest, because I didn't think she sounded like anyone else up on the stage. Her song choice was also very original, I felt. I quite enjoyed it.
10) Siobhan - Great song choice. Loved what she did with it. Fantastic voice.
11) Crystal - I'm... torn about her using up some of her singing time to play harmonica. But her voice is good and she's charming.
12) Katie - Ah, I couldn't not hear Adam during this and he did it better. My mom didn't have that problem and really enjoyed the performance.
The two people that I think were weakest and deserve to get cut are Lacey and Janelle (and possibly Haeley).
My mom's favorites are Siobhan, Paige, and Katie, though she feels none of them hold a candle to Allison's performance of "Alone"
My favorites are Didi, Siobhan, and Lilly (with Paige sneaking in there, too).
Okay, here goes...
1) Paige - she started the night off well with her performance. Powerful voice. I don't really remember seeing/hearing her before now but I really liked her sound.
2) Ashley - Didn't like the song very much. And she felt a little too smooth... didn't hit me the right way.
3) Janelle - Not terrific. Bad song choice (again - lots of those tonight).
4) Lilly - very jazzy voice; really liked what she did with the song.
5) Katelyn - Really good voice. Better than I remembered from before.
6) Haeley - Oh, horrible song choice for her and I didn't like what she did with it, either. Just didn't work for me at all.
7) Lacey - I love this song but I hated what she did with it. Did not like at all.
8) Michelle - I really enjoyed this one. Nice vibe; liked the song.
9) Didi - I don't know what Simon is smoking, to be honest, because I didn't think she sounded like anyone else up on the stage. Her song choice was also very original, I felt. I quite enjoyed it.
10) Siobhan - Great song choice. Loved what she did with it. Fantastic voice.
11) Crystal - I'm... torn about her using up some of her singing time to play harmonica. But her voice is good and she's charming.
12) Katie - Ah, I couldn't not hear Adam during this and he did it better. My mom didn't have that problem and really enjoyed the performance.
The two people that I think were weakest and deserve to get cut are Lacey and Janelle (and possibly Haeley).
My mom's favorites are Siobhan, Paige, and Katie, though she feels none of them hold a candle to Allison's performance of "Alone"
My favorites are Didi, Siobhan, and Lilly (with Paige sneaking in there, too).
(no subject)
Date: 2010-02-25 03:25 am (UTC)--via site search