I'm sure that's not what you were going for, but that's really how I took it the first time I read through your comments.
It... may be a simmering concern in my mind.
I think that the romance in Season One was well-done and not at all inexplicable and you think that it was rushed and badly-done and makes no sense. And if we reverse those things, we get to what we each think of Girl.
It is a bit dizzying, innit?
She's actually thrilled and happy to be on this journey with him, which has not always been true of companions in the past.
Truth, RTD is very keen on companions wanting to be there.
I just don't see where 'they get along' is Something Inexplicable.
Not so much that as he seems to get along with a lot of people, so it's just not really selling it to me on the uniqueness of their relationship.
Incidentally, what was the retcon in S2? I don't really see one.
Oh, the Sarah thing. Well, I know some that didn't see it as a retcon, but they were kind of hardcore Sarahshippers to start with. Though theoretically the love for Rose itself implies a Grand Retcon where the Doctor probably got it on with a few of his ex-companions, the Sarah thing sort of sealed it.
no subject
It... may be a simmering concern in my mind.
I think that the romance in Season One was well-done and not at all inexplicable and you think that it was rushed and badly-done and makes no sense. And if we reverse those things, we get to what we each think of Girl.
It is a bit dizzying, innit?
She's actually thrilled and happy to be on this journey with him, which has not always been true of companions in the past.
Truth, RTD is very keen on companions wanting to be there.
I just don't see where 'they get along' is Something Inexplicable.
Not so much that as he seems to get along with a lot of people, so it's just not really selling it to me on the uniqueness of their relationship.
Incidentally, what was the retcon in S2? I don't really see one.
Oh, the Sarah thing. Well, I know some that didn't see it as a retcon, but they were kind of hardcore Sarahshippers to start with. Though theoretically the love for Rose itself implies a Grand Retcon where the Doctor probably got it on with a few of his ex-companions, the Sarah thing sort of sealed it.